What's a Real Estate Comp List, and How Can It Help First-Time Homebuyers?

Posted by Twin Cities Habitat for Humanity on 10:35 AM on March 29, 2021

When you buy a home, how do you know what's a fair price? A home inspection can tell you if there are structural issues and a bank can tell you if you can afford it, but you can get a true sense of a "fair" price by comparing the prices of similar homes. That's where real estate comps come in.

"Real estate comparable listings" or "comps" for short provide information about the prices of homes similar to the one you’re looking at. A real estate agent can refer to comps to help you find out whether you'd be paying a fair price. Comp lists have tons of great data, so they can also help you learn more about your local housing market.

Why First-Time Homebuyers Should Get Real Estate Comps - black couple, real estate agent, realtor

Here's how real estate agents create comp lists and what you need to know about them as a homebuyer.

What's in a Real Estate Comp List?

Say you've found the perfect home that checks all your boxes. It's in the neighborhood you want, the commute would be great, and it's near a well-recommended school. The price tag seems normal, but you don't know the area very well.

[Here's What to Expect from the Twin Cities Housing Market in 2021]

A real estate agent will put together a real estate comp list of similar homes so you can find out if the price is typical for the area and home type. Comps also help sellers decide on a listing price. 

Comps can have a variety of criteria, but here are a few of the most common factors.

  • Homes near the one you want to buy. If you've ever heard the phrase "location, location, location," this is why. Location is the primary driver of home prices. That's why an agent will often limit their comp lists to just a mile or so from the home you want to buy. The closer to your target area you look, the better idea you have of home prices in that part of town.
  • Homes that have sold very recently. The home market is constantly in flux. Prices go up and down with living trends and local development. The Twin Cities housing market is currently a seller's market, meaning prices are going up because fewer people are selling their houses. But it could change any time based on economic changes and homeowner behaviors. A good real estate comp will factor in closing prices from the last few months. 
  • Homes that look like the one you want to buy, and with similar features. Obviously, more square footage usually means a higher price. The same goes for home features like recent renovations, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, views, driveway, garage, yard. When comparing home prices, try to match the features of another home to the one you want to buy and see how their prices stack up.

Remember: Appraisers get the final say. As the buyer, you will use the comps to decide how much you’re going to offer on the house. But after you sign the contract, the bank will call in a specialized appraiser to make sure they agree with your assessment. The bank has a vested interest in making sure that you don’t overpay for the house, since they hold your mortgage. That means no matter what you, the seller, and the agents say the house is worth, it’s up to the appraiser to confirm the price is fair.

Even first-time homebuyers can do a rudimentary version of a real estate comp list. Websites like Zillow, Trulia, and Redfin make it easy to narrow down your search by geographic location and put together a list for reference. But because they have experience and exclusive tools, a real estate agent can give you a deeper look into the current housing market. This can give you a crucial perspective on home prices and whether or not your dream home comes with a price tag to match.

Gain access to our First-Time Homebuyer Video Library! Watch and save homeowner tips.

Tags: Homebuyer Tips, Homeownership Program

Related Posts

What We're Grateful For in 2022

It's wonderful to have traditions like Thanksgiving that ask us to slow down, reflect, and give...

Read More

Home Provides a Hub for Friends, Family, and More

This summer, Twin Cities Habitat held a Homeowner Photo Contest for Habitat homeowners. Matias and...

Read More

My Best Memories Happened at My Nana's House

Sienna is 15 and a sophomore in high school. She shares this guest blog about how important her...

Read More

Get the latest Habitat stories, news, and event announcements delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe to our monthly Wire e-newsletter today!